Truth, Dare, double dare, torture, kiss or promise
When did not telling stories about your past become a form of lying? And why is it important to ‘know everything’? When Oscar Wilde said “The truth is rarely pure, and never simple” I am sure he was in a new relationship with a beautiful lady who depended on knowing his entire past, complete with every betrayal, pain, sexual conquest and regret. Oscar’s new flame would have delivered lines similar too “but I am your girlfriend we should share everything with each other” and “Do you have something to hide?” because let’s face it - for him to warrant such a profound and honest quote he would need to have had an insecure and demanding lady.
Oscar Wilde also said in a documented interview “No one has ever denied that relationships are hard; they are quite possibly one of the hardest life experiences and struggles any individual goes through”. The key word in the previous sentence is individual, and the irony is that although a relationship is the correlation of two people bonded together it is ultimately the connection of two individuals united. Oscar Wilde had the right mentality – relationships are about two individuals… Growing together. So with this in thought I propose to you, Why so often do people – particularly women – insist on knowing and sharing every crook and cranny about themselves, then furthermore expect their partner to divulge every single detail about themselves?
Now I understand that what I am about to say is an opinion – mine nonetheless - so I respect your rebuttals.
When you meet someone and start a life with them it is expected that you want to get to know them, understand them, fall in love with them and hear their stories. However, it is not tolerable or respected if you believe that a relationship develops a single collective brain! There is a lot about a person’s past (and probably present) that is a complete mystery and as a supportive partner, you should be ok with that. There is absolutely no need to know everything, it is not healthy, it is inhumane, and many things are just better left unknown.
You might have found your soul mate and you connect on a level with all-embracing love and openness, nevertheless there was a life before you met and that life shaped said soul mate, creating the person who you love and are with today. While I can understand that you would want to know what the events were that molded them, sometimes these are events that are only theirs and/or an event that is only shared with another person, which would possibly be disregarded or associated with confusion if spoken about with you, which could ultimately change the memory of the event. Now this does not counteract or change the way they feel about you nor does it devalue the relationship or cause any need to question trust, it just means that, as an individual you are entitled to your story, it does not need to be published.
The best proof of love is trust; Relationships are based on trust, you want your partner to trust you and in return you want to be able to trust your partner, If you cannot trust your partner, you do not have an honest relationship, therefore without trust there is no love so there is no relationship. It is regular statement that there should be no secrets in relationships and I do agree to that comment to a degree. When Charles Dickens said “Never close your lips to those whom you have opened your heart.” I doubt he was encouraging you to tell your significant about the time you participated an all night sex-romp orgy with some randoms and a one-night stand you picked up in New Orleans, nor did he want you to divulge into the time your best mate confided in you about her possible STi scare. This information is just a momentary distraction that need not be shared because it doesn’t serve any purpose except probably to hurt your present partner or potentially destroy the trust you developed with a friend. Not talking about certain situations or informing your new partner about previous experiences is not lying, I call it tact or social grace plus a little inaccuracy sometimes saves tons of explanation, not to mention prevents relationship insecurity.
Sometimes a lie, a false statement made with deliberate intent to deceive, seems the perfect response: a brother lies about his sister's where-a-bouts to the drunken husband threatening to harm her, a doctor tells a depressed patient that he has a 50-50 chance of long-term recovery when she is confident he'll live only six months, a son gives his late mother's estate to the poor after promising to honor her demand that the money be placed in her coffin. The same relates to relationships, why is it important to tell your girlfriend/boyfriend about the number of your previous sexual partners or about whom out of her/his friends you find attractive. More times than not honesty hurts and people who are brutally honest get more satisfaction out of the brutality than out of the honesty.
So is honesty in a relationship always the best policy? In fact, no. Nobody wants to hear that they look heavier or less attractive, nor do they want to hear how amazing their sex girlfriend was at fellatio. In truth, we consider those who are too honest to be blunt, antisocial and even pathological. A recent study found that adolescents who are most popular with their peers were the ones that were the best at being deceptive. And lying has proven psychological benefits. For instance, there’s scientific evidence showing that depressive people are more honest with themselves than non-depressive, or mentally healthy, people. When people recover from their depressions, they become less honest.
There is also the element of time… When is the right time to tell your partner your secrets? Relationships are always rocky in the beginning so why would you want to bare your heart and soul to someone who may not be around in six months? A new partner has no credentials or right to know some elements of your life. Plus a lot of secrets are shared secrets with other people who would not be happy or obliging to know that you are sharing such a deep intimate and private secret with someone else. The relationship you have with a partner is different to the relationship you have with a friend so it is expected that each relationship is consumed by different stories. Your partner does not want your best mate to know about her pimply bottom nor does your best mate want you to tell your partner about the time he passed out next to a transgendered midget and needed you to pick him up. All relationships, are volatile at best, so do you really want a mere fling, friendship or relationship, to know your deepest, darkest secrets?
Believe me; you're not doing anyone any favors by turning your personal life into an open book.
In summary… You should only know what your partner wants you to know, they deserve to have their past as do you because believe me the truthful past will hurt and cause doubt and suspicion. Let it be known there are only two times it is ok to tell the complete truth - anonymously and in a posthumous biography.